The success of UAVs in recent military operations has
generated considerable interest from many militaries around the world. In fact,
there is growing interest in extending the use of UAVs to operations other than
war, such as anti-terrorism support. Most will agree that the use of UAVs will
increase significantly over the next two decades; however, the use of UAVs is
not without risk. Unless a well-defined plan is put into place, the potential
exists for militaries to rush into committing to a platform and its related
infrastructure that will ultimately fail to meet their objectives.
To address this issue, in late 2002, the Canadian Forces
began a project to conduct concept development and experimentation with UAVs.
The objectives of this project are to evaluate the potential for UAVs to be
used in service and to help the Canadian Forces develop expertise that would
eventually lead to the purchase of UAVs. To support the concept development and
experimentation project, Defence Research and Development Canada, Ottawa, (DRDC
Ottawa) is making extensive use of modeling and simulation
technologies to support and improve the eventual acquisition
process.
DRDC Ottawa is one of six research centers within the Defence
R&D Canada organization, which is an agency of Canada's Department of
National Defence. DRDC Ottawa works in partnership with other government
departments, companies, universities, and research organizations worldwide to
enhance Canada's
military strength and industrial preparedness. Before
selecting an industry partner to assist in developing what is now called the
UAV Research Test Bed, Lieutenant Colonel Steve Newton from the Canadian Forces
Experimentation Center and DRDC Ottawa worked closely with Canadian Forces
officials to establish six areas that needed to be addressed when evaluating UAVs:
- Concept of Operations - How would the Canadian Forces
potentially use UAVs?
- Payloads - What might the UAVs carry, such as sensors or
surveillance equipment?
- Latency - Would there be any issues related to control and
communication with the operator on the ground?
- Human Factors - What potential human factor issues might
operators confront?
- Weapons - What weapon systems might the UAVs carry?
- Platforms - What existing UAV platforms should the Canadian
Forces consider?
To address these areas of investigation, DRDC Ottawa wanted
to develop a synthetic environment to be used for evaluating various scenarios,
identifying and improving capabilities, prototyping potential
systems, and ultimately supporting the acquisition process.
The synthetic environment would become the virtual world in which DRDC Ottawa
would conduct its evaluation and experimentation. CAE was selected to help DRDC
Ottawa develop and deliver the UAV Research Test Bed using some of CAE's
existing modeling and simulation development tools as well as new systems
developed specifically for UAV applications.
The Canadian Forces have taken a deliberate approach to
evaluating UAVs. The focus has been on identifying the capabilities required by
the military, and then determining if UAVs are the solution required to meet
the desired capabilities. With this philosophy, DRDC Ottawa has taken a
four-phase approach to the development of the UAV Research Test Bed. The first
phase, completed earlier this year, was designed to deliver a basic UAV
research capability in an open, modular system framework. Using existing
software and technologies, such as CAE's STRIVE simulation framework, the basic
UAV Research Test Bed was created in several months. The basic test bed
integrates a vehicle ground control station with a synthetic environment.
The ground control station (GCS), provided by CDL Systems,
includes an air vehicle operator workstation, mission payload operator workstation,
intercom system to support communications requirements, and visualization
system to provide a view of sensor data. The GCS software has been employed for
the control of operating UAV systems, in particular the U.S. Army Shadow 200
and Hunter. Through the standard high-level architecture protocol, the GCS
interfaces to the synthetic environment, which currently includes generic
models from CAE's existing library of sensors, air vehicles and other tactical
environment features. The synthetic environment in phase one supports a range
of simulated entities, and the capability exists to modify scenarios quickly,
including modification of wind speed and direction.
Phase Two of the development of the UAV Research Test Bed is
currently in progress and should be completed in the fall of this year. As part
of this phase, the UAV Research Test Bed will be significantly enhanced to
include specific functionality in both the GCS and synthetic environment. For
example, the synthetic environment framework will be developed to support
specific UAV platform characteristics and tuning of sensor models to specific
sensors. Phase Two will also see the GCS enhanced to support a display
capability for an infrared sensor image, as well as demonstration of compliance
with the NATO UAV interoperability protocol (STANAG 4586).
Following the successful completion of phase two, DRDC
Ottawa anticipates moving to the last two phases of the project to deliver a
robust UAV Research Test Bed for the Canadian Forces. By the end of the project
next summer, DRDC Ottawa expects the UAV Research Test Bed to have the
capability of modeling specific UAV platforms and sensor payloads. The
objective is then to evaluate various platforms in mission situations, such as
coastal and urban surveillance, and nuclear, biological, and chemical
detection. The UAV Research Test Bed also offers DRDC Ottawa scientists the
unique opportunity to experiment with future research areas for UAVs, such as
automatic target identification and autonomous decision-making.
The foundation for creating the UAV Research Test Bed is
modeling and simulation technology. STRIVE architecture and simulation
development framework is a next-generation, standards-based software
architecture and development framework that is actually a full suite of tools
and applications. Because STRIVE is a standards-based open framework, a range
of systems and applications can be made interoperable and reusable. The STRIVE
framework was ideal for the UAV Research Test Bed project because of its
flexibility to support the growing and changing requirements anticipated by
DRDC Ottawa as the project evolves.
The Canadian Forces UAV Research Test Bed project has
allowed CAE, in partnership with DRDC Ottawa, to develop a product called the
Reconfigurable Vehicle Control Station (RVCS). The RVCS is an integrated
product that combines a vehicle operator station with a synthetic environment
to support UAV research, training and operations. The vehicle operator station
can be reconfigured to control either a real air vehicle in a live mission, or
a simulated air vehicle in a synthetic environment. In the synthetic
environment, the simulated air vehicles operate against simulated terrain,
weather, and computer-generated forces and entities. STRIVE application is used
as the simulation framework as well as the application to develop the
computer-generated models.
Over the next several years, UAVs will see increasing use in
a variety of applications. The UAV Research Test Bed project is designed to
ensure the Canadian Forces have a disciplined and thorough understanding of UAVs
before committing limited budgets and resources. The RVCS
product is designed to assist other potential UAV users to
do the same. The basis for this low risk approach to UAV evaluation, acquisition
and operation is modeling and simulation technology, which is now finding
applications beyond traditional training systems and is being used extensively
throughout program lifecycles.Â
Drs. Paul Hubbard and Bumsoo Kim are with Defence R&D
Canada in Ottawa. Tobby Skeie is director, Technology Application with CAE.